Heisenberg's derivation of the
uncertainty relation for position and momentum. Click here for enlargement with explanation
Following Heisenberg's derivation of the uncertainty relations, one starts with an electron moving all by itself through empty space. To describe the electron, a physicist would refer to certain measured properties of the particle. Four of these measured properties are important for the uncertainty principle. They are the position of the electron, its momentum (which is the electron's mass times its velocity), its energy, and the time. These properties appear as "variables" in equations that describe the electron's motion.
|The uncertainty relations have
to do with the measurement of these four properties; in particular, they
have to do with the precision with which these properties can be measured.
Up until the advent of quantum mechanics, everyone thought that the precision
of any measurement was limited only by the accuracy of the instruments
the experimenter used. Heisenberg showed that no matter how accurate the
instruments used, quantum mechanics limits the precision when two properties
are measured at the same time. These are not just any two properties but
two that are represented by variables that have a special relationship
in the equations. The technical term is "canonically conjugate"
variables. For the moving electron, the canonically conjugate variables
are in two pairs: momentum and position are one pair, and energy and time
are another. Roughly speaking, the relation between momentum and position
is like the relation between energy and time.
The uncertainty relations involve the uncertainties in the measurements of these variables. The "uncertainty" -- sometimes called the "imprecision"--is related to the range of the results of repeated measurements taken for a given variable. For example, suppose you measure the length of a book with a meter stick. It turns out to be 23.6 cm, or 23 centimeters and 6 millimeters. But since the meter stick measures only to a maximum precision of 1 mm, another measurement of the book might yield 23.7cm or 23.5 cm. In fact, if you perform the measurement many times, you will get a "bell curve" of measurements centered on an average value, say 23.6 cm. The spread of the bell curve, or the "standard deviation," will be about 1 mm on each side of the average. This means that the "uncertainty" or the precision of the measurement is plus or minus 1 mm.
|The uncertainty relations can be
written a little more precisely in the shorthand of mathematical
symbols. But first we must define what these symbols stand for. Here are
Dq is the uncertainty or imprecision (standard deviation) of the position measurement.
Dp is the uncertainty of the momentum measurement in the q direction at the same time as the q measurement.
DE is the uncertainty in the energy measurement.
Dt is the uncertainty in the time measurement at the same time as the energy is measured.
h is a constant from quantum theory known as Planck's constant, a very tiny number.
p is pi from the geometry of circles.
> means "greater than or equal to"
Putting these symbols together, the two uncertainty relations look like this:
Let's say you measure the position of a moving electron with such great accuracy that Dq is very small. What happens to the precision of the momentum Dp, which you measure at the same instant? From the first relation, we have
Dp > h / 4 p Dq
You can see that the uncertainty in the momentum measurement, Dp is very large, since Dq in the denominator is very small. In fact, if the precision of the position measurement gets so great that the uncertainty Dq gets so small that it approaches zero, then Dp gets so large that it approaches infinity or becomes completely undefined.
To see if the uncertainty relations are more than just a mathematical result, Heisenberg considered a thought experiment.
Click for Heisenberg's analysis of the gamma-ray microscope.
From this thought experiment, and another for energy and time, Heisenberg concluded that the mutual uncertainties in position and momentum or energy and time really do exist. They are not the fault of the experimenter or the apparatus. They are a fundamental consequence of the quantum equations, built into every experiment in which quantum mechanics comes into play.
Click for Heisenberg's conclusions regarding the impact of the uncertainty relations on physics.