Optimism and Other Poems

Optimism and Other Poems

A Deep Dive into an NBLA Acquisition

A thin bookmark with the remains of a frayed yellow tassel at one end is tucked in between two pages of the open book. In handwritten cursive it reads: "Watch your friends your enemies can't hurt you."

This bookmark was tucked in the pages and likely belonged to an early owner. It reads: “Watch your friends your enemies can’t hurt you.”

Photo credit Allison Rein.

The Niels Bohr Library & Archives has recently acquired a rather unusual book of poetry and photographs written by missionary and physicist Laura Dickinson. Despite its unassuming cover, this book, entitled Optimism and Other Poems, has some unique touches, including an inscription by the author to a “Cousin Carrie,” as well as, still tucked within its pages, a bookmark belonging to an early owner. Cousin Carrie was likely Dickinson’s second cousin, Carrie Gaylord, who worked at Spelman College as a Matron and then Hostess. Inside the book are 40 short poems, as well as 6 photographs also taken by Dickinson.

Portrait of a young woman in three-quarter profile wearing a light-colored dress with a dark bow tie circa the late 1800s. Her hair is pulled back except for short curly bangs in the front

Laura Dickinson in her early life. Photo possibly taken around the time she was a student at Mount Holyoke College.

Photo credit Mount Holyoke College Archives and Special Collections.

This book is also notable for the history of its author, who lived a relatively obscure life, but one devoted to what might seem today to be an unusual combination of professions – that of science education and missionary work.

Laura Austin Dickinson was born in North Amherst, Massachusetts on November 15, 1870. She had two siblings, a brother Raymond and a sister Louisa. A common question I’ve had since starting to research Dickinson – and especially since finding out that she wrote poetry – is if she is related to the well-known Emily Dickinson. And the answer is yes! Although not very closely. Laura and Emily were third cousins through their great great grandfather.

Family tree showing the relationship of Laura and Emily Dickinson through their great great grandfather Nathan Dickinson.

The familial relationship between Laura and Emily Dickinson is likely that of third cousins, which means they shared a great-great grandfather. Information gathered from FamilySearch.org.

In 1889 Laura Dickinson and her sister enrolled at Mount Holyoke College on the Seminary track. At this time, at Mt. Holyoke and many other colleges, college courses were set series of classes with very little variation among students. Mt. Holyoke offered three tracks – the Classical, the Scientific, and the Seminary. The Classical emphasized ancient languages, history, and literature, while the Scientific emphasized a larger amount of science, mathematics, and the “Modern Languages” (German or French). The Seminary track fell somewhere in the middle. However, students on all tracks were required to take a breadth of certain courses considered essential to a basic education – among which was physics.

In this sepia photograph, the camera peaks over the top of a lab bench to capture Marcia Keith sits with head bent amidst laboratory equipment at Mount Holyoke College.

Marcia Keith in her laboratory in Williston Hall. Keith taught physics at Mount Holyoke between 1885 and 1903.

Photo credit Mount Holyoke College Archives and Special Collections.

All students took a basic introductory physics course in their junior year which used Atkinson’s translation of Ganot as the textbook, accompanied by some work in the laboratory. (This was likely Edmund Atkinson’s Elementary Treatise on Physics Experimental and Applied, which was a translation of Adolphe Ganot’s Traité élémentaire de physique expérimentale et appliquée. This book was an enormously popular introductory physics textbook in the nineteenth century.) Dickinson would have taken her physics class with Professor Marcia A. Keith. Keith, who worked at Mount Holyoke College between 1885 and 1903, is famous as one of the two women present at the founding of the American Physical Society - the other being Isabelle Stone, who was then a professor of physics at Vassar College.

After graduation Dickinson devoted herself to teaching and missionary work. Dickinson was one of many female physicists who taught at missionary schools in the United States or abroad in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Mount Holyoke College especially produced many female scientist-missionaries, including other physicists like Sara Boddie Downer and Edith Marion Coon. Science was a vehicle for missionary work, and vice versa.

a slim book, maybe a centimeter deep, with a red cover and embossed gold lettering reading "Optimism and Other Poems" and "Laura Dickinson"

Last year NBLA acquired this copy of Optimism and Other Poems by Laura Dickinson, published in 1929.

Photo credit: Allison Rein.

 In the fall of 1913 Dickinson went to teach at Spelman Seminary. Spelman had been founded in 1881 by white northern female missionaries with backing from John D. Rockefeller and the American Baptist Home Mission. Spelman offered academic, industrial, and religious education to uplift Black women while holding them to strict ideals of respectable Black Christian womanhood. When she applied, Dickinson was asked to discuss in her application (among other things):

  • Her success as a teacher
  • Her success as a disciplinarian
  • Her personal appearance
  • And her Christian character

These were not unusual questions to ask at the time, but it is useful to note as it helps to remind us just how much the professors were expected to model ideal personality traits, hygiene, and Christian ethics for their students. (The history of the social significance of hygiene ties into the history of eugenics, which is a fascinating discussion but one which will have to wait for another time!)

Dickinson’s poem “The Maker” illustrates how Dickinson saw the divine in the workings of the universe.

Photo Credit Allison Rein.

At first Dickinson worked as a librarian and taught science classes for the Seminary’s high school track, but the institution was on an upward growth trajectory, and so was she. In 1924 Spelman Seminary became Spelman College. That year Dickinson took a sabbatical to the University of Michigan, where she earned a Master’s in Physics, and returned to take her new position as the college’s first Professor of Physics and Chemistry. Spelman College continues to flourish as one of a few Historically Black women’s colleges – and it is currently the only one to offer a major in physics.

Laura Dickinson taught at Spelman College until 1933 when she retired to care for her ailing sister. During the summers, she took classes from Columbia University, the University of Michigan, the University of Chicago, and the American Academy in Rome. And it was at the Academy that she took the photographs featured in her 1929 book, Optimism and Other Poems. She later published another book of poetry and photographs, entitled Pen Pictures, in 1937.

The text of "Electrons and Protons" reads in part: "Dear little wizards, moving hither and yon; / Sedate wee particles, more firmly fixed; / Long did you escape our eager quest." etc.

Dickinson’s poem “Electrons and Protons” is included in a subsection of Dickinson’s book entitled “Laboratory Musings.”

Photo Credit Allison Rein.

Dickinson’s poems in Optimism speak to her own faith and its motivating role in her life. In a section entitled “Laboratory Musings” Dickinson includes a poem entitled “Electrons and Protons” as well as one entitled “The Maker.” Including “The Maker” among her Laboratory Musings clearly indicates the connection Dickinson made between work in the laboratory and understanding the role of the Divine in the world. And the language she uses to discuss the subatomic particles in “Electrons and Protons” is nothing short of reverential.

The idea that religion and science are fundamentally opposed to each other is routinely debunked in the history of physics. From Kepler to Maxwell, there have been numerous examples of religious physicists who viewed their efforts to understand the natural world as intimately connected to their faith. Laura Dickinson’s poetry offers an opportunity to explore the relatively understudied world of women who melded science and religion in pursuit of occupational opportunities as educators and missionaries.

Recommended Reading:

  • Case, Sarah H. Leaders of Their Race: Educating Black and White Women in the New South. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2017.
  • Levin, Miriam R. Defining Women’s Scientific Enterprise: Mount Holyoke Faculty and the Rise of American Science. Hanover: University Press of New England, 2005.
  • Read, Florence M. The Story of Spelman College. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1961.
  • Richardson, Joe M. and Jones, Maxine D. Education for Liberation: The American Missionary Association and African Americans, 1890 to the Civil Rights Movement. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 2009.
  • Rossiter, Margaret. Women Scientists in America: Struggles and Strategies to 1940. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1982.

I must also give thanks to Holly Smith and Kassandra Ware of the Spelman College Archives and to Deborah Richards of the Mount Holyoke College Archives and Special Collections. I did research about Dickinson at each of these institutions and their help was invaluable. You can read some more of this research as well as more about Dickinson’s life in this History Newsletter article.

About the Author

Joanna Behrman

Joanna Behrman

Joanna Behrman was the Assistant Public Historian at the Center for History of Physics (CHP). She holds a Ph.D. from Johns Hopkins University and specializes in the history of women in physics. At CHP she was in charge of education and outreach projects. One of her favorite works in the collection is Dorothy Weeks’s unpublished memoir.

Caption: Madalyn Avery, Household Physics Laboratory Manual (New York: Macmillan Company, 1940), page 8

See all articles by Joanna Behrman

Add new comment

Plain text

  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You can align images (data-align="center"), but also videos, blockquotes, and so on.
  • You can caption images (data-caption="Text"), but also videos, blockquotes, and so on.
  • You can embed media items (using the <drupal-media> tag).


Submitted byElizabeth Behrmanon Thu, 04/15/2021 - 08:35

You should see if a publisher is interested in publishing it, with you as editor. Also, please correct the spelling of your name in the link.