What’s Ahead
Science Committee Starts Session with Climate Change Hearing
On Wednesday, the House Science Committee is dedicating its first hearing of the year to discussing “the state of climate science and why it matters.” Committee Chair Eddie Bernice Johnson (D-TX) has said one of her top priorities for the new Congress is to tackle the problem of climate change, “starting with acknowledging it is real, seeking to understand what climate science is telling us, and working to understand the ways we can mitigate it.” All five witnesses are climate scientists, two of whom were co-authors of the Fourth National Climate Assessment: Kristie Ebi, who directs the Center for Health and the Global Environment at the University of Washington, and Robert Kopp, director of the Rutgers Institute of Earth, Ocean, and Atmospheric Sciences. Also appearing are Woods Hole Research Center scientist Jennifer Francis and Natalie Mahowald, faculty director for the environment at the Cornell University Atkinson Center for a Sustainable Future. The Republican-invited witness is Joseph Majkut, director of climate policy at the Niskanen Center.
Stopgap Funding Deadline Arrives Friday
The stopgap spending measure that ended the 35-day partial government shutdown last month is set to expire on Friday. Negotiations on a compromise border security package have stalled , raising the prospect of another shutdown, though it is possible that lawmakers could extend the stopgap measure to buy more timeWhite House officials have reportedly signaled that President Trump would be open to signing such a measure.
NSF Board to Discuss US Innovation Enterprise
The National Science Board is meeting Tuesday at the National Science Foundation’s headquarters in Alexandria, Virginia. In the public portion of the meeting, the board will hear a plenary talk on “American Business Innovation” by Chris Liddell, who is deputy chief of staff for policy coordination at the White House. In a separate plenary session, two former board members — physicist Barry Barish and former Director of Defense Research and Engineering Anita Jones — will share their views on “future challenges and opportunities for the U.S. science and engineering enterprise.” The board will also discuss a summary document on “foreign born students and workers in the U.S. S&E enterprise,” which it produced in response to broad interest in the topic.
AAS Hosting Rescheduled NASA and NSF Town Halls
The American Astronomical Society will hold webinars this week to make up for the cancellation of two agency town hall meetings at its January meeting due to the government shutdown. On Wednesday, officials from NASA’s Science Mission Directorate will discuss the status of Astrophysics Division programs, planning for the upcoming decadal survey, and upcoming grant and mission proposal opportunities. On Friday, the director of the National Science Foundation’s Astronomical Sciences Division will provide updates on facilities and grant programs, the division budget, and engagement with the research community.
AAAS Meeting Spotlights ‘Science Transcending Boundaries’
The annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science is convening this week in Washington, D.C. With the theme of “science transcending boundaries,” the meeting will explore how science can “help address the many divisions in our communities, in global society, and in science itself.” The meeting will feature plenary sessions with high-level officials from government science agencies from around the world. Fabiola Gianotti, the director-general of European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN), will speak on the role of international collaboration at the organization. In conjunction with the meeting, AAAS is also hosting back -to-back science policy networking events on Saturday.
UPDATE: On Friday, Kelvin Droegemeier will make his debut appearance as director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy at a newly announced special session, which will be webcast .
In Case You Missed It
Senators Hear Case for Aggressive Investment in Energy R&D
At a Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee hearing on Feb. 7, committee members heard from a panel of witnesses eager to impress on them the importance of increased investment in a diverse portfolio of energy R&D. Bipartisan Policy Center President Jason Grumet endorsed the American Energy Innovation Council’s longstanding advocacy for tripling U.S. energy R&D funding. Former Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz agreed, saying a “very, very large increase in our investment” is needed, while acknowledging the likelihood of encountering “fiscal headwinds.” He suggested that “new, dedicated funding streams” might be a way to fund additional R&D. Conveying the recommendations of a new report by the Energy Futures Initiative, which he leads, he urged spreading federal investment across energy sources and technologies and all stages of the R&D and commercialization process. Committee Chair Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) reiterated her own support for investment in energy R&D, saying, “It is time to push hard to bring down the cost of clean energy technologies like renewables, advanced nuclear, next-generation energy storage, and carbon capture.”
‘Innovation’ a Theme at House Climate Hearings
At two hearings on Feb. 6, lawmakers from both parties pointed to supporting “innovation” as a primary way in which the federal government should respond to climate change. Rep. Paul Tonko (D-NY), who chairs the Environment Subcommittee of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, called climate change “this generation’s Sputnik moment,” calling for a “moonshot” effort to address the problem. Rep. Greg Walden (R-OR), the committee’s top Republican, said his caucus is “focused on solutions that prioritize adaptation, innovation, and conservation. ... we want America’s innovators to develop the next technologies that will improve the environment and create jobs here at home.” House Natural Resources Committee Chair Raul Grijalva (D-AZ) called for a broader approach, saying that “we know that we need more than innovation, we need good policies.” However, Republican lawmakers are criticizing the recent “Green New Deal” proposal backed by many Democrats, including Grijalva, that calls for a sweeping transformation of the U.S. energy system and major economic reforms.
DOE to Restrict Collaboration with ‘Sensitive’ Countries
The Department of Energy plans to restrict its employees and grantees from collaborating with foreign nationals from countries it deems “sensitive,” according to an internal memorandum obtained by ScienceInsider last week. Issued late last year by Deputy Energy Secretary Dan Brouillette, the memo establishes an advisory board responsible for developing and updating a science and technology “risk matrix” that lists the sensitive countries on one axis and certain “emerging research areas and technologies” on the other. DOE employees and grantees working in these areas will generally be “prohibited” from collaborating with individuals from the corresponding countries on the matrix, though the department can grant exceptions on a case-by-case basis and for certain categories of engagement, such as government-to-government agreements. Under Secretary for Science Paul Dabbar, who is responsible for fleshing out the policy with the department’s other under secretaries, told ScienceInsider that DOE employees will be forced to resign and grantees will lose the ability to compete for DOE grants if they do not comply with the policy. In a related move, DOE issued a separate memorandum last month that prohibits its employees and grantees from participating in foreign talent recruitment programs operated by “sensitive” countries.
Republicans Name House Science Subcommittee Leaders
House Science Committee Ranking Member Frank Lucas (R-OK) revealed the Republicans’ subcommittee leadership assignments last week at the committee’s first business meeting of the new Congress. Two of the party’s most active committee members, Reps. Randy Weber (R-TX) and Brian Babin (R-TX), are remaining as the top Republicans on the Energy Subcommittee and Space and Aeronautics Subcommittee, respectively. Rep. Roger Marshall (R-KS) is taking over from Rep. Andy Biggs (R-AZ) as top Republican on the Environment Subcommittee. Rep. Ralph Norman (R-SC) is now ranking member of the Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee, taking the slot previously held by Rep. Ralph Abraham (R-LA), who has left the committee. The ranking member of the Research and Technology Subcommittee is Rep. Jim Baird (R-IN), who is new to Congress. Baird previously served as a representative in the Indiana General Assembly. However, he began his career as a livestock specialist with the Purdue University Cooperative Extension Service after earning a doctorate in animal science monogastric nutrition from the University of Kentucky in 1975. The subcommittee’s former chair was Rep. Barbara Comstock (R-VA), who lost her seat in the November election.
Senate Energy Committee Announces Subcommittee Leaders
The Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee released the membership rosters for its four subcommittees last week. Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) is the new chair of the Energy Subcommittee, which has jurisdiction over the Department of Energy. The former chair, Sen. Cory Gardner (R-CO), now chairs the Science, Oceans, Fisheries, and Weather Subcommittee of the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee. Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-NM) is the Energy Subcommittee’s ranking member, taking over from Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV), who now chairs the full committee. A vocal advocate for the nuclear security laboratories in his state, Heinrich is also ranking member of the Strategic Forces Subcommittee of the Senate Armed Services Committee, which has jurisdiction over the nation’s nuclear weapons complex.
Restructured Intelligence Committee Includes Research Panel
Last week, the House Intelligence Committee announced it has reorganized and that its new structure includes a subcommittee dedicated to “strategic technologies and advanced research.” The panel will oversee the “development and implementation of emerging and advanced technologies that are essential to intelligence collection and national security” and work to ensure the U.S. “remains at the cutting edge in overhead systems, artificial intelligence/machine learning and computing, as well as data and systems integrity.” Reps. Jim Himes (D-CT) and Chris Stewart (R-UT) will serve as the subcommittee’s chair and ranking member, respectively. Previously, technological issues were subsumed within an Emerging Threats Subcommittee that has been eliminated in the new structure.
OSTP Elaborates on President’s Reference to ‘Industries of the Future’
In his third state of the union address , President Trump made a brief reference to supporting “cutting-edge industries of the future” as a part of potential infrastructure legislation. Shortly after the speech, the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy issued a statement identifying artificial intelligence, advanced manufacturing, quantum information science, and next-generation wireless communication technology as examples of such industries. The administration is planning to take actions in support of these technology areas in the coming months. Trump is expected to sign an executive order imminently to establish a national AI initiative. In his address, Trump also called for increased investments in health R&D to cure HIV and childhood cancers.
Trump Picks Acting Secretary for Top Job at Interior Department
President Trump announced on Feb. 4 that he plans to nominate Acting Interior Secretary David Bernhardt to lead the department, succeeding former Secretary Ryan Zinke. Republican senators have expressed support for Bernhardt’s nomination, though he may face opposition from Democrats due to his prior work as a lobbyist for industries regulated by the department. While serving as deputy secretary under Zinke, Bernhardt issued an “open science” directive that echoes a similar, controversial proposal awaiting final action at the EPA.
NASA’s Lunar Science Plans Get Lukewarm Endorsement in Twin Reports
The National Academies released two short reports on Feb. 7, evaluating the scientific components of NASA’s new lunar exploration campaign. One of the reports verifies that NASA’s plans align with the scientific priorities for lunar science set out in the most recent National Academies decadal survey for planetary science. However, it states those plans should not be regarded as a replacement for the mid-scale projects that the survey recommended: the Lunar South Pole-Aitken Basin Sample Return mission and the Lunar Geophysical Network. The report recommends the new activities should still be formally evaluated within the context of NASA’s planetary science program by the next decadal survey, which is due for release in 2022. The second report concentrates on NASA’s plans to integrate lunar science with commercial services. While it finds commercial landers could provide valuable scientific results, it warns the “interfaces” between scientific instrumentation and such landers remain “undefined,” which could lead to program delays.
National Academies Releases Materials Research Decadal Survey
On Feb. 8, the National Academies released a report surveying the current status of materials research in the U.S. and identifying promising areas for work in the coming decade. Among its recommendations, it calls on the federal government to develop a national strategy for ensuring stakeholders can access and develop midscale instruments and laboratory infrastructure, such as materials growth facilities and helium recycling systems. It also recommends that agencies sustain and “in some cases” increase support for fundamental research in “long-established” materials research fields, while reinforcing newer R&D efforts in additive manufacturing, quantum materials science and engineering, and the application of “computational methods, data analytics, machine learning, and deep learning” to materials research. Unlike some other decadal surveys, the report does not rank research priorities. The survey was co-chaired by National High Magnetic Field Laboratory Chief Scientist Laura Greene, University of Pennsylvania physicist Tom Lubensky, and Matt Tirrell, Argonne National Laboratory’s deputy director for science. The three will discuss the survey’s findings and recommendations in a webinar on Feb. 28.
NASA Updates Research Community at Post-Shutdown Town Hall
NASA Science Mission Directorate head Thomas Zurbuchen hosted a virtual town hall event on Feb. 7 to update the community on NASA programs following the recent partial government shutdown. Zurbuchen said the agency’s immediate priorities include supporting their workers, eliminating confusion over deadlines, and expediting timelines for returning to normal operations. Regarding NASA missions, he said, “some milestones may be delayed, but there are no significant changes to launch readiness dates.” He also reported that proposal deadlines, including for the Research Opportunities in Earth and Space Science (ROSES-18), NASA’s annual general solicitation for basic and applied research proposals, will be no earlier than to March 29 in most cases. Slides and audio from the town hall are available here .
Events This Week
Monday, February 11 National Academies: “Evolving the Geodetic Infrastructure to Meet New Scientific Needs,” meeting two
(continues through Wednesday)
Beckman Center (Irvine, CA)
Tuesday, February 12 NSF: National Science Board meeting
8:00 am - 5:15 pm, NSF headquarters (Alexandria, VA)
Webcast available
National Academies: “STEM Education Day”
9:00 am - 5:00 pm, National Academies of (2101 Constitution Ave. NW, DC)
Webcast available
Hudson Institute: “The Case for Reforming the Missile Technology Control Regime”
11:45 am - 1:30 pm, Hudson Institute (1201 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, DC)
AAS: Rescheduled NASA town hall
12:00 - 1:00 pm, webinar
UMD: “Science and National Security”
4:00 pm, University of Maryland (College Park, MD)
Exchange Monitor: Nuclear Deterrence Summit
(continues through Thursday)
Sheraton Pentagon City (Arlington, VA)
Wednesday, February 13 National Academies: “Decadal Assessment of Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Science,” meeting four
(continues through Friday)
Keck Center (500 5th St. NW, DC)
Closed to the public
House: “The State of Climate Science and Why it Matters”
10:00 am, Science Committee (2318 Rayburn Office Building)
DOE: “The Value Proposition for Advanced Nuclear,” congressional briefing
11:30 am - 1:00 pm, 208-9 Capitol Visitors Center
JHU: “From Dominance to Diplomacy: The U.S. Approach to Advances in S&T”
4:15 - 6:15 pm, John Hopkins University SAIS (1717 Massachusetts Ave. NW, DC)
SETI: “The Future of NASA Space Telescopes – What to Look for in the Next Generation”
7:00 - 8:00 pm, SRI International (Menlo Park, CA)
Thursday, February 14 AAAS: Annual meeting
(continues through Sunday)
Omni Shoreham Hotel (2500 Calvert St. NW, DC)
Stanford: “CO2 Emissions on the Rise: Leading Causes, Practical Solutions”
12:00 - 2:00 pm, National Press Club (529 14th St. NW, DC)
NASA: Forum on Lunar Exploration Plans
12:30 pm, NASA headquarters (300 E St. SW, DC)
Webcast available
ADDED -- NSF/UKRI: Conversation on future directions for LIGO research
1:00 - 1:45 pm, Marriott Wardman Park (2660 Woodley Road NW, DC)
DNFSB: Business meeting
1:00 - 4:00 pm, Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board (625 Indiana Ave. NW, DC)
Stanford/Duke: “Climate Change: Examining the Science, Technology, and Policy Options,” congressional briefing
4:00 - 5:30 pm, 268 Capitol Visitor Center
Friday, February 15 No events start today.
Saturday, February 16 AAAS: Science Policy Networking Mixer
7:00 - 8:30 pm, Omni Shoreham Hotel (2500 Calvert St. NW, DC)
ESEP: “Science Policy Shindig”
8:30 - 11:00 pm, Seasons and Sessions (2427 18th St. NW, DC)
Opportunities
ITIF Seeking Energy Innovation Policy Analyst
The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation is hiring a senior policy analyst for its clean energy innovation program. The analyst will assess policies that “have the potential to influence the national and global transition to a low-carbon energy system, such as research, development, and demonstration funding, taxation, and regulation.” Applicants must have a graduate degree in a relevant field and at least three years of relevant experience.
AMS Washington Forum Registration Open
The American Meteorological Society is holding its Washington Forum in D.C. on March 27 through 29. The annual event brings together scientists and top federal officials to discuss policy issues related to the weather, water, and climate sciences. This year’s forum includes sessions on hurricane resiliency, the value of weather information, “smart farming,” and applications of artificial intelligence in the weather industry.
American Geosciences Institute Hiring Summer Interns
The American Geosciences Institute is accepting applications for its summer policy internship programs. Applicants must be undergraduate or early-stage graduate students in the geosciences or a geo-related engineering field. Applications are due March 1.
Know of an upcoming science policy opportunity? Email us at fyi@aip.org.Know of an upcoming science policy event? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Around the Web
News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.
White House
- Trump unveils his America-first approach to AI (Wired, perspective by Michael Kratsios)
- US State of the Union disappoints science advocates (C&EN)
- Trump’s State of the Union address ignores climate change (Eos)
- How HIV/AIDS ended up in Trump’s State of the Union speech (ScienceInsider)
- Scientists kick the tires on Trump’s plan to tackle HIV (Nature)
Congress
- Letters to agencies requesting shutdown impacts (House Science Committee)
- Interview with House Science Environment Subcommittee Chair Lizzie Fletcher (D-TX) (Houston Matters, audio)
- Rep. Kendra Horn (D-OK) to make debut as Space Subcommittee chair at commercial space conference (SpacePolicyOnline)
- Rookies lead the way on House science panel (ScienceInsider)
- The GAO is stepping up efforts to help lawmakers get smart on technology issues (FCW)
- Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), a STEM fan, is running for president (Education Week)
Science, Society, and the Economy
- The economic impact of industrial physics on the US economy (APS, report)
- The importance of innovation in physics (perspective by James McKenzie)
- Taxation and innovation in the 20th century (Cato Institute, report)
- If it innovates, tax it, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez suggests (Wall Street Journal, perspective by Safi Bahcall)
- In Los Alamos county, lab is larger employer of shrinking workforce (Exchange Monitor)
- Katharine Hayhoe: ‘The true threat is the delusion that our opinion of science somehow alters its reality’ (Wired)
Education and Workforce
- Physics PhDs ten years later: Duties and rewards in academic positions (AIP, report)
- Rise of the temporary workforce in science (Nature)
- Why some scientists choose to forgo promising careers abroad to return to their countries of birth (Nature)
- Perceived anti-China bias and dearth of jobs have Chinese science students in US mulling their options (South China Morning Post)
- International graduate-student enrollments and applications drop for 2nd year in a row (Chronicle of Higher Education)
- Texas A&M to lead NSF study of sexual harassment in STEM fields (Texas A&M University)
- APS Bridge Program and the National Mentoring Community visit Google HQ (APS News)
Research Management
- Overdue: A US advisory board for research integrity (Nature, perspective by C. K. Gunsalus, Marcia McNutt, et al.)
- NSF plays catch-up on 111 deferred grant reviews (Government Executive)
- Thousands of scientists run up against Elsevier’s paywall (Nature)
- Statement of The Optical Society on Plan S (OSA)
- Government data, commercial cloud: Will public access suffer? (Science, perspective by Mariel Borowitz)
- Can machines determine the credibility of research claims? The Center for Open Science joins a new DARPA program to find out (Center for Open Science)
- Nicole Nelson probes key moments in reproducibility crisis (Harvard Gazette, interview)
- They say a scientist molested them as children. Now they want his scientific legacy to reflect that. (BuzzFeed News)
- The grant funding lottery and how to fix it (Nature, audio)
- Creativity and collaboration: Revisiting cybernetic serendipity (PNAS)
Labs and Facilities
- CERN considers a 100 TeV circular hadron collider (Physics Today)
- Physicists await Japanese government decision on the International Linear Collider (Physics World)
- UCLA leads development of first-of-its-kind telescope for gamma-ray astronomy (UCLA)
Energy
- ‘Green New Deal’ doc phased out nuclear — until it didn’t (E&E News)
- How do you dismantle a nuclear power plant? Very, very carefully. (Washington Post)
- How the US can keep its energy innovation edge (Morning Consult, perspective by Ernest Moniz)
- Catalyzing clean energy innovation (NRDC)
- National Energy Technology Lab releases compendium of carbon capture technology (NETL)
- Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy: A roadmap (IDA)
- Energy executive leadership academy provides tools to transform energy (NREL)
- Lawrence Livermore National Lab, universities form high energy density science alliance (LLNL)
- An energy wish list for the new Congress (New York Times, perspective by Justin Gillis and Hal Harvey)
Quantum Science and Technology
- NIST narrows field of post-quantum crypto contenders (GCN)
- IBM unveils world’s first integrated quantum computing system for commercial use (IBM)
- Q-FARM initiative to bolster quantum research at Stanford-SLAC (Stanford University)
- The future of tech: Building quantum technology with ion beam accelerators (IAEA)
- How quantum terrorists could bring down the future internet (MIT Technology Review)
Space
- NASA: Join us in going to the Moon … and beyond (OZY, perspective by Jim Bridenstine)
- NASA has taken a significant step toward human landings on the Moon (Ars Technica)
- Farside politics: The West eyes Moon cooperation with China (Scientific American)
- Thousands of NASA contractors still without pay after 5-week shutdown. Will Congress step in? (Orlando Sentinel)
- CASIS seeks to increase awareness of ISS national lab with name change (SpaceNews)
- Beyond Mars, the mini MarCO spacecraft fall silent (NASA)
- A Johns Hopkins APL team has a plan to deflect an asteroid (Baltimore Sun)
- ESA’s Mars rover has a name — Rosalind Franklin (ESA)
- We need more powerful nuclear engines to explore father and faster into space (MIT Technology Review, perspective by Erin Winick)
Weather, Climate, and Environment
- How much is the government spending on climate change? We don’t know, and neither do they (FiveThirtyEight)
- Americans were a lot less worried about climate change before Trump took office (FiveThirtyEight)
- New chapter in climate change politics begins with simultaneous House hearings (ScienceInsider)
- Leader of new climate panel talks of need for ‘bold action’ (ABC News, interview with Rep. Kathy Castor (D-FL))
- Climate select committee Dems still rely on fossil fuels (E&E News)
- ‘It’s crazy. It’s loony': Republicans giddy as Democrats champion Green New Deal (Politico)
- Boulder’s NCAR in agreement with NOAA to upgrade forecast modeling (Boulder Daily Camera)
- Researchers create new scale for atmospheric rivers, a major source of California’s water (Los Angeles Times)
Defense
- Putin warns that Russia is developing ‘invincible’ hypersonic missiles (New York Times)
- Russia bids farewell to INF Treaty with fresh nuclear development plans (DefenseNews)
- Members reintroduce bicameral bill banning low-yield nukes (Rep. Ted Lieu (D-CA))
- The US and Russia are sleepwalking toward nuclear disaster (Politico, perspective by Sam Nunn and Ernest Moniz)
- SRNS given millions for pit production, MOX transition work, nuclear agency says (Aiken Standard)
- ‘I’m not confident at all': Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) casts real doubt on DOE (Aiken Standard)
- Did the US government ship plutonium to Nevada without telling lawmakers? (Snopes)
- Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto may place holds on nominees over plutonium spat (E&E News)
- US sues Lockheed, others for alleged kickbacks on nuclear site cleanup (Reuters)
- NASA Goddard Space Flight Center director nominated to lead National Reconnaissance Office (SpaceNews)
Biomedical
- As Cuba medical mystery deepens, State Department turns to new National Academies panel for answers (Yahoo News)
- NIH asks inspector general to investigate 12 allegations of foreign influence in US research (STAT)
- New patent win for University of California upends CRISPR legal battle (ScienceInsider)
- Stanford will investigate its role in the Chinese CRISPR baby debacle (MIT Tech Review)
International Affairs
- Transcending boundaries (Science, perspective by Margaret Hamburg)
- EU’s new rules place restrictions on open publication of research data (Science|Business)
- What non-EU countries want from Horizon Europe (Science|Business)
- Row over Horizon Europe raises risk of delay (*Research)
- The big challenge: Defining scientific excellence (Science|Business)
- Violence and insecurity threaten Mexican telescopes (ScienceInsider)
- Lawmakers fret about China’s investment in 5G (Washington Post)
- Stanford halts research ties with Huawei amid surveillance controversy (Stanford Daily)
- Turkey creates its first space agency (Nature)
- Impact of women in STEM roadshow in India (APS News)
- MIT chief decries Khashoggi killing but won’t cut Saudi ties (AP)
- Embattled cooperation(s): Peaceful atoms, pacifist physicists, and partisans of peace in the early Cold War (Physics in Perspective, paper by Stefano Salvia)