What’s Ahead
Midterm Election’s Science Policy Impacts Will Remain To Be Seen
Science policy is unlikely to be the foremost subject on voters’ minds as they head to the polls on Tuesday. Nevertheless, the election results will have consequences for federal support for science, though they will likely remain unclear for some time. One looming issue is the expiration next October of the two-year spending cap agreement that enabled recent funding increases for science. Following budget sequestration in 2013, Congress has never allowed the caps to return to their original, tightest levels, but, in a volatile political environment, it is unclear how Democratic control of the House or Senate could affect negotiations. Beyond the budget, a Democratic majority would be able to call hearings and conduct oversight on subjects of their choosing. House Science Committee Democrats have identified climate change and the use of science at the Environmental Protection Agency as high priorities. But, without control of the White House, their ability to make laws would remain limited to matters on which there is bipartisan agreement.
Influential Science Policy Voices in Close Races
Elections for individual seats will have consequences primarily via their implications for committee activities. Most notably, Rep. John Culberson (R-TX) is in a tight race. In his role as chair of a House appropriations subcommittee, he has championed NASA, pushed forward two missions to Jupiter’s moon Europa, and generally resisted calls for Congress to control the allocation of funding among the National Science Foundation’s directorates. In other races, Sen. Bill Nelson (D-FL) , the ranking member of the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee, is believed to hold a narrow lead in his bid for reelection, as is Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) , who chairs the committee’s Space, Science, and Competitiveness Subcommittee. Three prominent Republican members of the House Science Committee — Reps. Dana Rohrabacher (R-CA) , Barbara Comstock (R-VA) , and Randy Hultgren (R-IL) — are also in difficult contests.
Congress Returning Nov. 13 for Lame Duck Session
Newly elected members of Congress will take their seats on Jan. 3. In the meantime, the current Congress will return on Nov. 13 for its “lame duck” session. High on the agenda is completing the appropriations process for fiscal year 2019. Currently, many agencies are operating with stop-gap appropriations, including NASA, the National Science Foundation, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Institute of Standards and Technology, U.S. Geological Survey, and Environmental Protection Agency. If Democrats gain control of one or both chambers, they may push to defer a final agreement until the next Congress when they would have more leverage over the legislation. It is possible that some science policy legislation will advance during the lame duck session. In particular, work on the bipartisan “National Quantum Initiative Act” gained significant momentum before Congress left on its pre-election recess.
Quantum Leaders Converging in Chicago
Top federal officials are heading to the Midwest for a two-day summit at the University of Chicago late this week that will highlight local and national efforts to advance quantum information science. The university recently announced it will help develop a 30-mile quantum communication link between Argonne National Laboratory and Fermilab. The three institutions have also partnered to form the Chicago Quantum Exchange , which aims to increase collaboration between scientists at the labs and the university. Representatives of the Department of Energy, National Science Foundation, National Institute of Standards and Technology, and Department of Defense will deliver keynote addresses at the event, which will be webcast.
Space Studies Board to Discuss Lunar Science Possibilities
The National Academies Space Studies Board is meeting Wednesday through Friday in Irvine, California. There will be an extensive discussion of research that could be enabled through the orbiting lunar outpost and commercial partnerships that are central to NASA’s vision for its new lunar exploration campaign. Representatives from the board’s standing committees and NASA’s science advisory committees will also be discussing “challenges and opportunities” in their respective fields. Other presentations will address the James Webb Space Telescope, small-scale satellites, the European space landscape, the upcoming astronomy and astrophysics decadal survey, and the recent midterm assessment of the last planetary science decadal survey.
National Academies Hosting Convocation on Sexual Harassment
The National Academies is convening leaders from academia, government, and professional societies on Friday to discuss promising policies and strategies to prevent sexual harassment in academia. The convocation builds on the recommendations of the recent National Academies report on the issue and comes as some federal agencies and scientific societies are advancing initiatives to combat sexual harassment. Morning plenaries will focus on moving beyond legal compliance toward prevention, responding to misperceptions about sexual harassment, and discussing the role of federal agencies. Afternoon breakout sessions will shift to developing new strategies for training, data collection, reporting mechanisms, and improving organizational culture.
Student Group Convening Science Policy Symposium
The East Coast branch of a federation of student groups called the National Science Policy Network is convening a symposium in New York City this weekend, bringing together early career scientists who share an interest in policy, advocacy, and diplomacy. The symposium features sessions on careers in science policy, basics of science advocacy, and science communication. The plenary speaker is Kerri-Ann Jones, who served as assistant secretary of state for oceans and international environmental and scientific affairs from 2009 to 2014.
In Case You Missed It
DOJ Launches Effort to Counter Chinese Economic Espionage
Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced on Nov. 1 that the Department of Justice has begun a “China Initiative” to crack down on the country’s allegedly systematic efforts to steal American intellectual property. Top U.S. attorneys outlined the initiative at a press conference during which DOJ unsealed the latest in a series of indictments connecting the Chinese government to economic espionage activities. In addition to allocating more resources to trade secret theft cases, Sessions said the department will seek to better protect non-traditional targets, such as universities. A fact sheet on the initiative states the department will “develop an enforcement strategy concerning non-traditional collectors (e.g., researchers in labs, universities, and the defense industrial base) that are being coopted into transferring technology contrary to U.S. interests.” The FBI, which is within DOJ, has made a concerted effort to increase awareness about such non-traditional collection efforts this year, raising the subject in congressional hearings and briefings to academic institutions.
Astro2020 Decadal Survey Receives Marching Orders
On Oct. 29, the National Academies released its statement of task for the upcoming decadal survey for astronomy and astrophysics. The survey report is expected to be released about two years from now, whereupon it will become the guiding document for NASA, the National Science Foundation, and Department of Energy as they develop the relevant portions of their science portfolios. In addition to reviewing the state of the field and prioritizing major projects, the survey, unlike its prior iterations, will recommend decision rules to guide agency responses to changing budgets and undertake a detailed assessment of the state of the astronomy and astrophysics profession. A document detailing the scope of the survey notes that, in addition to considering future projects, it should advise NASA on the scale of its commitments to the Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope (WFIRST), the Advanced Telescope for High-Energy Astrophysics (ATHENA), and the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA). Jim Lancaster, director of the National Academies Board on Physics and Astronomy, said last week that he expects the survey committee leadership will be announced within days, and by December at the latest.
NASA Concludes Kepler and Dawn Missions
NASA announced the conclusion of two science missions last week, the Kepler space telescope and the Dawn spacecraft . Launched in 2009, Kepler was the first telescope designed specifically to search for exoplanets. A year after a mechanical failure ended its initial mission in 2013, it entered a second phase of operation called K2 that allowed it to continue making observations until its fuel was depleted. The mission, which had a lifecycle cost of about $600 million, has to date resulted in the confirmed discovery of over 2,600 exoplanets, with additional results expected to emerge from its data archives. Dawn, which had a lifecycle cost of about $500 million, was the first spacecraft to orbit an object in the Solar System’s main asteroid belt and the first to orbit two extraterrestrial bodies. It launched in 2007 and rendezvoused with the asteroid Vesta in 2011 before moving on to the dwarf planet Ceres, where it remained until its fuel was expended. Both Kepler and Dawn were developed through NASA’s Discovery program, which was created in the 1990s to foster relatively low-cost missions performing focused scientific investigations.
NASA Reorganizing Astrobiology Efforts
NASA announced on Nov. 1 that it is transforming its Astrobiology Institute into an array of “research coordination networks” (RCNs). The Astrobiology Institute is a “virtual institute” that was created in 1998 and is administered by a small staff at NASA’s Ames Research Center in California. The new RCNs will be self-organized by researchers and modeled on the existing Nexus for Exoplanet System Science . NASA expects new networks devoted to life detection, ocean worlds, prebiotic chemistry and the early Earth, and cell formation will be created by the end of 2019. The reorganization conforms to recommendations in the recent National Academies strategies for exoplanet research and astrobiology to foster collaboration across NASA’s science divisions. It will not alter how NASA funds research related to astrobiology.
New Supercomputer to Triple Berkeley Lab’s Computing Power
The Department of Energy announced on Oct. 30 that the National Energy Research Scientific Computing (NERSC) Center at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory has signed a $146 million contract with Cray to build a pre-exascale supercomputer. Called Perlmutter, after astrophysicist Saul Perlmutter, the machine is expected to more than triple the computational power currently available at NERSC. It will be used to run large-scale simulations and analyze the increasingly vast datasets produced by vanguard scientific facilities.
Los Alamos National Lab Management Transition Complete
On Nov. 1, the management contract for Los Alamos National Laboratory transferred to Triad National Security, a non-profit consortium led by the University of California, Texas A&M University System, and Battelle Memorial Institute. Thom Mason, the consortium’s CEO and former director of Oak Ridge National Laboratory, is now serving as the national security lab’s twelfth leader in its 75-year history. According to the lab, nearly all of its employees were retained in the transition, with only a few senior leadership personnel changing under the new management. The Department of Energy recompeted the contract after a series of nuclear safety mishaps at the lab led to a loss of confidence in its management.
NNSA Updates Stockpile Stewardship and Nonproliferation Plans
Last week, the National Nuclear Security Administration released the first annual reports to Congress on its nuclear weapons stockpile stewardship and non-proliferation programs since the Trump administration issued its Nuclear Posture Review this February. Together, the reports provide a synoptic view of NNSA’s efforts to maintain and modernize the U.S. nuclear arsenal in the absence of underground testing while also guarding against the spread of nuclear materials around the globe. The reports outline approaches for addressing challenges that face NNSA’s R&D programs and identify overarching concerns related to infrastructure and workforce development.
Report Lauds NIST Physics Divisions, Flags Long-Term Issues
A National Academies review of four physics divisions in the National Institute of Standards and Technology released last week offers a glowing assessment of their scientific expertise and identifies long-term challenges to their vitality. The review panel concludes the divisions’ capabilities remain world class overall, although it also observes that some staff are located in a building that has not been upgraded since the 1960s and are “rapidly reaching the day when the decaying infrastructure will limit their ability to perform their necessary duties.” It further calls on NIST and the University of Colorado Boulder to fund renovations at their joint research institute, JILA, writing that the oldest wing of the lab is “simply incompatible with the extraordinary experiments being pursued there.” It also raises concern about JILA’s reliance on a Physics Frontier Center grant from the National Science Foundation, identifying a need to plan for the eventuality that the center is not renewed.
Events This Week
Monday, November 5 OSA: Optical Society Laser Congress
(continues through Thursday)
Boston, MA
GWU: “In Search of Evidence-Based Science Policy: From the Endless Frontier to SciSIP”
1:00 - 2:30 pm EST, George Washington University (1957 E St. NW, DC)
Tuesday, November 6 National Academies: “Panel on Review of In-house Laboratory Independent Research in Physics at the Army’s R&D Centers”
(continues through Thursday)
Open sessions: 9:30 am - 3:30 pm, Tue; 8:30 am - 3:00 pm, Wed
National Academy of Sciences (2101 Constitution Ave., DC)
NASA: Venus Exploration Analysis Group
(continues through Thursday)
Johns Hopkins University (Laurel, MD)
Webcast available
NSF: Astronomy and Astrophysics Advisory Committee teleconference
12:00 - 1:00 pm
National Academies: Plasma 2020 Town Hall at APS Division of Plasma Physics Annual Meeting
7:00 - 9:00 pm PST, Oregon Convention Center (Portland, OR)
Wednesday, November 7 National Academies: Space Studies Board meeting
(continues through Friday)
Open sessions: 8:50 am - 5:30 pm PST, Wed; 9:00 am - 6:00 pm PST, Thu
Beckman Center (Irvine, CA)
Webcast available
ITIF: “Losing Power? The State of the Global Race for Batteries to Power Electric Vehicles and Modernize the Grid”
12:00 - 1:30 pm, Information Technology and Innovation Foundation (1101 K St. NW, DC)
Webcast available
Harvard Science Policy Group: “Science Policy in California, the Fifth Largest Economy”
5:30 - 7:00 pm, Harvard University (Cambridge, MA)
Thursday, November 8 NSF: Fall 2018 Grants Conference
(continues Friday)
8:00 am - 6:00 pm, Thu; 8:00 am - 4:00 pm, Fri
InterContinental New Orleans (New Orleans, LA)
National Academies: “Astrochemistry: Discoveries to Inform the Chemical Sciences and Engineering Communities”
(continues Friday)
8:30 am - 5:00 pm, Thu; 8:30 am - 12:00 pm, Fri
Keck Center (500 5th St. NW, DC)
Webcast available
Chicago Quantum Exchange: Chicago Quantum Summit
(continues Friday)
9:30 am - 7:00 pm, Thu; 9:00 am - 12:30 pm, Fri
University of Chicago (Chicago, IL)
Webcast available
Research!America: 2018 Post Election Briefing
10:00 - 11:30 am, AAAS headquarters
Hudson Institute: “Space 2.0: The Intersection of Space Policy and the FCC”
11:30 am - 12:50 pm, Hudson Institute (1201 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, DC)
FASEB: “Election 2018: Impact on Science Funding and Policy Issues”
2:00 - 3:00 pm, Webinar
National Academies: “Review of the USGS Laboratories: Process, Procedures, and Best Practices to Meet National Needs,” meeting three
(continues Friday)
Menlo Park, CA
Friday, November 9 National Academies: “Together We Can Do Better: A Convening of Leaders in Academia to Prevent Sexual Harassment”
8:30 am - 3:30 pm, National Academy of Sciences (2101 Constitution Ave. NW, DC)
Webcast available for morning sessions
Saturday, November 10 National Science Policy Network: Science Policy Symposium
(continues Sunday)
8:30 am - 7:30 pm, Sat; 9:00 am - 12:00 pm, Sun
Rockefeller University (New York, NY)
Sunday, November 11 APLU: Association of Public and Land-Grant Universities Annual Meeting
(continues through Tuesday)
New Orleans Marriott (New Orleans, LA)
Monday, November 12 National Academies: “Review of the SBIR/STTR Programs at DOE,” meeting four
(continues Tuesday)
Keck Center (500 5th St. NW, DC)
International Astronomical Union: Astronomy for Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion symposium
(continues through Friday)
National Astronomical Observatory (Tokyo, Japan)
League of European Accelerator-based Photon Sources: 2018 Plenary Meeting
(continues through Wednesday)
Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (Hamburg, Germany)
Invitation only
Opportunities
CRS Hiring Earth Sciences Section Head
The Congressional Research Service is accepting applications for a research manager to lead the Natural Resources and Earth Sciences Section of its Resources, Science, and Industry Division. Among the position responsibilities are leading the development of objective policy analysis for congressional staff on regulatory and scientific issues related to public lands, water resources, ecosystems, and natural hazards. Applications are due Nov. 27.
American Academy of Arts & Sciences Policy Fellowship Application Open
The American Academy of Arts and Sciences is accepting applications for the 2019-2020 Hellman Fellowship in S&T Policy program. Fellows develop expertise on issues of science, engineering, and technology policy and contribute to projects focused on challenges facing scientific research and education. Individuals must have a Ph.D. in a science or engineering field. Applications are due Jan. 7.
NOAA Science Advisory Board Seeking Members
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is accepting nominations for its Science Advisory Board. Members are appointed by the head of NOAA for three-year terms. NOAA is specifically seeking individuals with expertise in cloud computing; artificial intelligence and data management; weather modeling and data assimilation; remote/autonomous sensing technology; ocean exploration science and technology; and “omics” science. Nominations are due Nov. 30.
Know of an upcoming science policy opportunity? Email us at fyi@aip.org.Know of an upcoming science policy event? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Around the Web
News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.
White House
Congress
- Should Congress revive the Office of Technology Assessment? (American Action Forum, perspective by Will Reinhart)
- Rep. Frank Lucas (R-OK) is eying House Science Committee chairmanship (Politico, interview)
- Midterms and science: Florida Senate, Sen. Bill Nelson (D) vs. Gov. Rick Scott (R) (AGU)
- Midterms and science: CA-48, Rep. Dana Rohrabacher (R) vs. Harley Rouda (D) (AGU)
- Midterms and science: TX-07, Rep. John Culberson (R) vs. Lizzie Fletcher (D) (AGU)
- Some Republicans in close races are (ever so slightly) changing their tune on climate change (Washington Post)
- With hurricanes and toxic algae, Florida’s gubernatorial candidates can’t ignore the environment and climate change (InsideClimate News)
Political Engagement
- Signal Boost: October 2018 (American Physical Society, video)
- Scientist-politicians go local: from lab bench to a deep bench (Nature)
- Supporting science policy advocacy and outreach through microgrants (Union of Concerned Scientists)
Science, Society, and the Economy
- American tech firms are winning the R&D spending race with China (Wall Street Journal)
- The covert politics of cold-war science (Nature, book review)
Education and Workforce
- NSF reviewing program that graduate fellows to study abroad (ScienceInsider)
- Contract lecturers are a growing yet precarious population in higher education (Physics Today)
- Semiretirement is treating me well — and it made room for a younger scientist (ScienceInsider, perspective by Richard Larson)
- National Academies report says sexual harassment is a threat to engineering (IEEE Spectrum, perspective by C. D. Mote, et al.)
- With student interest soaring, Berkeley creates new data-sciences division (Chronicle of Higher Education)
- Girl Scouts can now earn space science badges (Eos)
- International Astronomical Union seeks proposals to host Office of Astronomy for Education (IAU)
- Defense industry calls for STEM talent (Signal Magazine)
Research Management
- Wellcome and Gates join bold European open-access plan (Nature)
- Meet Octopus, a new vision for scientific publishing (Science)
- Peer review: The worst way to judge research, except for all the others (New York Times, perspective by Aaron Carroll)
- A huge database of scientific retractions is live. That’s great for science. (Vox, perspective by Julia Belluz)
- The bitter class struggle behind our definition of a kilogram (The Atlantic)
- The future for learned societies (Physics World, perspective by Paul Hardaker)
- Raghuveer Parthasarathy’s big idea for fixing science (Andrew Gelman Blog)
- Science Cities 2018 (Nature Index)
- Learning through citizen science: Enhancing opportunities by design (National Academies, report)
- LIGO to publish paper on noise analyses in wake of investigation (New Scientist)
- Interdisciplinarity: A Nobel opportunity (arXiv, paper by Michael Szell, et al.)
- Keeping the door open to international scientific collaboration (Worcester Telegram, perspective by Robert Dempski)
- Scientists are about the change what a kilogram is. That’s massive. (Washington Post)
Labs and Facilities
- Hawaiian Supreme Court approves Giant Telescope on Mauna Kea (New York Times)
- Wanted: Researchers for China’s mega telescope (South China Morning Post)
- This is how astronomy is finally defeating its greatest enemy: Earth’s atmosphere (Forbes)
- SLAC joins new LaserNetUS network to boost high-intensity laser research (SLAC)
- Why physics needs, and deserves, a post-LHC collider (Forbes, perspective by Ethan Siegel)
Energy
- Perry loves his job. That could change after the election (E&E News)
- Department of Energy announces two landmark technology transfer initiatives (DOE)
- DOE studying making fuel at INL for advanced reactors (Idaho Post Register)
- Review of the draft analysis of supplemental treatment approaches of low-activity waste at the Hanford Nuclear Reservation (National Academies, report)
Quantum Science and Technology
- Europe shows first cards in €1-billion quantum bet (Nature)
- Europe’s ‘Quantum Flagship’ officially sets sail (Optics and Photonics News)
- EU ministers double down on quantum computing (*Research)
- Universities, national laboratories join forces to push Chicago into lead on quantum technology (University of Chicago)
- ‘Are we there yet?’ Orienting the map to quantum computing (CloudTech, perspective by Travis Humble)
- The forgotten quantum pioneer who turned wartime spy (Nature, book review)
Space
- On Kepler’s retirement (Physics Today)
- Farewell, Kepler (Planetary Society)
- Update on Opportunity rover recovery efforts (NASA)
- Telescope drama could thwart the hunt for extraterrestrial life (Gizmodo)
- Independent board chair calls JWST a ‘step too far’ (SpaceNews)
- Putting astrobiology at the heart of NASA science (Space Review)
- Satellite repair and refueling demos may soon spur a new industry (Physics Today)
- A group of scientists want to launch a satellite to make an artificial aurora (Popular Mechanics)
- 30 years of gravitational-wave astronomy (Physics World)
- Enabling scientific input to a national space strategy (American Astronomical Society)
Weather, Climate, and Environment
- One year later, why is Trump’s pick for NOAA administrator still not confirmed? (E&E News)
- US Supreme Court allows historic kids’ climate lawsuit to go forward (Nature)
- Shipping regulators plan to cut greenhouse-gas emissions (The Economist)
- Real-world planetary climate management? Governance is the hard part (Living on the Real World, perspective by William Hooke)
- Geoengineering could stop warming but comes with side of sea-level rise (Ars Technica)
- Countries urge increased international research in the Arctic (Eos)
- California’s new earthquake warning system delivers just seconds of notice. Even that is a victory (Science)
Defense
- Six lab directors discuss the biggest national security challenges of the future (Los Alamos National Lab)
- China’s military sends more scholars abroad, at times without schools’ knowledge (Wall Street Journal)
- Zia Mian on scientists, the nuclear threat, and a treaty to ban nuclear weapons (Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, interview)
- Nuclear weapons sustainment: FY18 nuclear forces budget estimates (GAO, report)
- Defense nuclear enterprise: DOD continues to address challenges but needs to better define roles and responsibilities and approaches to collaboration (GAO, report)
- After laser attacks, Pentagon spending $200M to protect pilots’ eyeballs (Defense One)
- Next phase of Electronics Resurgence Initiative announced (DARPA)
Biomedical
- Federal agencies clash on cellphone cancer risk (AP)
- Heart failure stem cell trial to be paused after calls for retractions (Washington Post)
- Web service makes big data available to neuroscientists (Nature)
- What contributes to the success of early career scientists? – A NIAID look (NIH)
- Why public funding is vital for biomedical research (San Diego Union Tribune, perspective by Richard Huganir)
- Science cities, stealing IP, and hyper-competition: a China hand’s intelligence briefing (STAT, interview with Robert Desimone)
International Affairs
- Trump’ victory in Brazil stuns scientists (Nature)
- Brazil’s new president adds to global threat to science (Nature, editorial)
- Australian academics fear political interference following vetoed projects (Nature)
- Australia plans ‘national-interest’ test for research grants (Nature)
- Australia should aspire to be a leader in strategic space diplomacy through science (Australian Strategic Policy Institute, perspective by Annie Handmer)
- The challenges of Chinese space cooperation (SpaceNews, perspective by Jeff Foust)
- Most Chinese scientists write academic papers to get promoted, survey finds (South China Morning Post)
- Picking flowers, making honey: The Chinese military’s collaboration with foreign universities (Australian Strategic Policy Institute, report)
- Chinese scientists want to conduct research in US waters — should Washington let them? (The National Interest, perspective by Ryan Martinson and Peter Dutton)
- English, Chinese, and science (Axios)
- In Iran, four conservation scientists face espionage charges that carry the death penalty (ScienceInsider)
- Barcelona, capital global de la diplomacia científica (La Vanguardia, perspective by Alexis Roig)
- ETH Zurich starts process to dismiss astronomy professor accused of bullying students (ScienceInsider)
- Brexit budget ‘will not get UK to 2.4% target’ (*Research)
- Proposed visa change would hit thousands of UK university posts (*Research)
- Who gets the money? Gender and UK research council funding (*Research, perspective by Alison Hay)
- Priorities for the European Open Science Cloud (Science|Business, report)
- Universities say no to ‘Europe first’ vision for research (Science|Business)
- Tear down visa barriers that block scholarship (Nature, perspective by Connie Nshemereirwe)