FYI: Science Policy News
FYI
/
Article

Pessimistic Report Issued by GAO on SSC

MAR 05, 1993

The General Accounting Office has released a report that opponents of the Superconducting Super Collider will be citing for the rest of the year. In repeated criticisms about accounting practices, schedule and cost overruns, and possible downsizing of the detectors, the GAO paints what can only be described as a sobering future for the project. Although DOE takes strong issue with GAO (see FYI #28), this new report will make the annual task of securing an appropriation for the facility all the more difficult.

GAO examiners concluded that “analyses of the major subcontractors’ work in progress show that the SSC project is over budget and behind schedule.” They criticize the yet-to-be completed Cost and Schedule Control System, noting that it will not be fully functioning until at least this July. At GAO’s request, the Department of Energy analyzed subcontractors’ reports, and concluded that conventional construction (tunnels, etc.) is 19% behind schedule, and 51% over baseline cost. Using trend analyses, two “major magnet subcontractors predicted that their development contracts will have cost overruns of $53 million (25%) and $25 million (37%).”

DOE is employing a “build-to-cost strategy” to prevent overruns for the SSC’s two large detectors, costing around $1.1 billion. The SSC budget would provide $596 million of this amount, with the remainder to come from DOE’s High Energy Physics Program ($80 million), foreign funding ($329 million), the State of Texas ($35 million), and “to be determined” ($99 million.) There are varying degrees of optimism about the likelihood of obtaining this funding. If the necessary money is not secured, the detector collaborations are proposing to defer installation of some components, a strategy which could shutdown the entire SSC for up to 12 months. The GAO reports “the effects of [the above] cost-cutting on physics experiments, according to the SSC Laboratory’s Associate Director, Physics Research Division, is difficult to determine until the amount of required reduction is known. The effect of shutdowns is also unknown.” The DOE Project Director is also considering whether to defer construction of the one of the detectors, a move that many physicists fear might lead to its cancellation. The GAO concludes that “DOE’s use of a build-to-cost strategy to counter increased project costs could result in a major downsizing of the SSC if costs continue to increase.”

In concluding comments, the GAO states, “Early projections of the major subcontractors’ progress indicate that the cost growth could be substantial. To combat increased costs, DOE is pursuing a build-to-cost strategy, which appears to be merely deferring costs to a date after the completion of SSC construction. Therefore, we caution that completion of the SSC project may require more than the annual amounts provided for in the project’s funding profile or more than the $5.5 billion total that DOE recently reported to the Congress.”

More from FYI
FYI
/
Article
Senate appropriators propose modest budget increases for NSF and NASA science, in contrast to the House, ahead of the Dec. 11 funding deadline.
FYI
/
Article
NSF employees say their new headquarters is a major downgrade from their old building, with poor telecommunications connectivity and limited meeting spaces.
FYI
/
Article
Decisions on spending and White House control over science grants await a lame-duck Congress.
FYI
/
Article
Former NOAA officials say the dramatic changes increase the risk of data loss and will degrade the agency’s satellite capabilities.
/
Article
A traveling science demonstration can reach thousands of young students interested in STEM. Help inspire the next generation with these tips on creating your own science van.
/
Article
Writing is a classic choice for generating interest and engagement in STEM. You can wordsmith your way to a professional writing career with the following advice.
/
Article
High-speed videos reveal how a detached stinger uses a dual-piston mechanism to burrow into skin and pump a continuous flow of venom.
/
Article
Thoughtful collaborations can spark inspiration for both disciplines. If you want to conduct science outreach through the arts, this advice can help you get started.
/
Article
After a successful first road trip, antimatter could one day be delivered by vehicle to university labs.

Related Organizations