FYI: Science Policy News
FYI
/
Article

Lessons Learned: GAO Report on the CRAF/Cassini Missions

FEB 04, 1994

A General Accounting Office report released this week provides insights into NASA’s decision to cancel the CRAF mission and to redesign the upcoming Cassini mission. This report is must reading for anyone interested in how NASA made these decisions, as well as for a review of the promises and problems of the 1997 Cassini mission to Saturn.

House science subcommittee chairman James Hayes (D-LA) requested this year-long study, which was based on interviews with NASA and Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) officials and the Chairman of the Space Studies Board, as well as document review. The report covers two main topics: the CRAF cancellation and the subsequent restructuring of the Cassini mission.

GAO found that the CRAF mission was squeezed on two fronts. The projected cost of a key instrument, the comet nucleus penetrator, increased from an initial estimate of $22 million to as much as a projected $120 million. This escalation caused NASA to cancel the instrument, undercutting the mission’s justification. GAO found, however, that a 1992 National Research Council report (in GAO’s words) “stated that the CRAF mission had great scientific merit even without the penetrator experiment.” Two other instruments were also eliminated.

Also squeezing CRAF were congressional budget restrictions on mission expenditures. NASA concluded that it had no choice but to eliminate CRAF, and make certain cost-reducing design changes in Cassini. An October 1992 Space Studies Board report concluded that Cassini’s primary scientific objective will not be substantially compromised, although some research opportunities will be lost. Somewhat ominously, NASA has shifted, according to a 1992 JPL estimate, $94 million in Cassini development phase work to the much-beleaguered Mission Operations and Data Analysis account. GAO also reports on several potential problems which could reduce this mission’s effectiveness.

GAO found little documentation of the CRAF decision, and concluded that “no studies or analyses were done to evaluate whether to cancel CRAF or pursue an alternative means of accomplishing CRAF’s missions.” Commenting on the report, science subcommittee member Connie Morella (R-MD) stated, “We must not forget the lessons learned from the cancellation of the CRAF mission as Congress begins preparations for a more austere NASA budget. Space science missions, notably, the Cassini mission, could be profoundly affected.”

For a single free copy of “Space Science - Causes and Impacts of Cutbacks to NASA’s Outer Solar System Exploration Missions” (GAO/NSIAD-94-24) call GAO at 202-512-6000.

More from FYI
FYI
/
Article
Senate appropriators propose modest budget increases for NSF and NASA science, in contrast to the House, ahead of the Dec. 11 funding deadline.
FYI
/
Article
NSF employees say their new headquarters is a major downgrade from their old building, with poor telecommunications connectivity and limited meeting spaces.
FYI
/
Article
Decisions on spending and White House control over science grants await a lame-duck Congress.
FYI
/
Article
Former NOAA officials say the dramatic changes increase the risk of data loss and will degrade the agency’s satellite capabilities.
/
Article
A traveling science demonstration can reach thousands of young students interested in STEM. Help inspire the next generation with these tips on creating your own science van.
/
Article
Writing is a classic choice for generating interest and engagement in STEM. You can wordsmith your way to a professional writing career with the following advice.
/
Article
High-speed videos reveal how a detached stinger uses a dual-piston mechanism to burrow into skin and pump a continuous flow of venom.
/
Article
Thoughtful collaborations can spark inspiration for both disciplines. If you want to conduct science outreach through the arts, this advice can help you get started.
/
Article
After a successful first road trip, antimatter could one day be delivered by vehicle to university labs.

Related Organizations