FYI: Science Policy News
FYI
/
Article

Harvard Professor Found Guilty in High-Profile China Initiative Case

JAN 03, 2022
Will Thomas
Spencer R. Weart Director of Research in History, Policy, and Culture
101013_Features_084.jpg

A gate on the Harvard campus.

(Kris Snibbe / Harvard University)

After deliberating for less than three hours, a jury convicted Harvard University chemistry professor Charles Lieber on Dec. 21 on charges of lying to federal investigators about his participation in a Chinese talent recruitment program and failing to report income he received through the arrangement to the IRS.

During the one-week trial, prosecutors presented video of an interrogation in which Lieber admitted to receiving tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars in compensation from the Wuhan Institute of Technology that he did not disclose, and said he was unaware of how China classified him in response to questions about his talent program participation.

While Lieber’s lawyers argued it could not be proven he was lying on that point, the prosecutors presented a contract he signed making him a participant in the program and pointed to his admission of not being transparent with officials from federal science agencies.

Lieber’s case represents the first time a jury has rendered a guilty verdict against an academic in a case brought through the Justice Department’s China Initiative and follows the acquittal of another scientist after a judge concluded prosecutors could not reasonably prove their case.

The initiative has come under fire from advocacy groups for focusing on crimes related to disclosure of funding rather than more serious charges of espionage and theft, as well as for predominantly affecting scientists of Asian descent.

Despite Lieber’s conviction, some observers believe the department may soon ease up on its prosecutions of academics. In the coming months, several more China Initiative cases are scheduled to go to trial, including those of University of Kansas chemistry professor Franklin Tao, University of Arkansas engineering professor Simon Saw-Teong Ang, and Texas A&M University professor Zhendong Cheng.

Related Topics
More from FYI
FYI
/
Article
The House has proposed a nearly $500 million cut to NIH, far short of the White House’s request.
FYI
/
Article
The project aims to design fellowships that can withstand changes in federal funding, following significant reductions to NSF’s graduate fellowships this year.
FYI
/
Article
A recent executive order looks to officially establish political review processes that staff say are already being implemented at NSF.
FYI
/
Article
The AI Action Plan released last week pushes science agencies to expand researcher access to high-quality scientific data and AI resources.