Reconstructing Niels Bohr: A Conversation with Philip Ball
In this installment of our interview series, I’m pleased to speak with journalist and author Philip Ball about his new biography, The Man Who Broke Reality: Niels Bohr and the Making of Modern Physics
Bohr at blackboard, Physics Today Collection, Courtesy Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Physics Today Collection. Catalog ID: Bohr Niels A2
Among the sources Ball draws on most frequently are oral history interviews preserved in AIP’s appropriately named Niels Bohr Library & Archives. The book includes some 50 citations to these interviews, including conversations with Niels Bohr
Trevor Owens: You’ve written extensively about the history and concepts in science, from the history of the elements
Philip Ball: Having written previously about quantum mechanics (in Beyond Weird), I have felt for some time that the Copenhagen interpretation, which Bohr shaped more than anyone else, often gets an unfair hearing these days. It—or rather, a somewhat simplified and often rather misleading version of it—is typically regarded as the textbook orthodoxy that fudges the challenging interpretational issues of quantum mechanics and is ripe for replacement with one of the many alternatives now available. I don’t think Bohr’s vision of quantum mechanics adequately addresses the interpretational aspects, but I think it was more subtle and in many ways more radical than it is given credit for. So part of my motivation was to redress this. And as I began to look more deeply into Bohr’s thought as the quantum centenary approached in 2025, I was amazed to find that there was really no biography of him written for the general reader in English since Ruth Moore’s 1966 book, which was understandably a product of its time. I also became increasingly aware of Bohr’s prescience about an arms race after the Second World War, and of his efforts to avoid it—an issue that interests me very much as someone who has also written a lot about the social responsibilities of science. This aspect of his life’s work is not so well known, but deserves to be. Bohr is now seen as a pioneer of the modern idea of science diplomacy, whereby the international and collaborative nature of the scientific enterprise might be leveraged to improve political discourse between nations. So it seemed to me that a new biography of Bohr was very much overdue—one that might take into consideration the scholarship of the past several decades on the origins of quantum mechanics and the debates between Bohr and Einstein.
TO: There is substantial historical literature on Bohr and the development of quantum mechanics. Which earlier works most shaped your approach, and what new perspectives did you hope to offer?
PB: Yes, there is indeed! Helge Kragh is surely the foremost modern expert on these issues. Abraham Pais’s thorough intellectual biography Niels Bohr’s Times (1991) was also an immensely valuable source: it is rather forbidding for a general reader, but summarizes a great deal of the historical material. John Heilbron’s Niels Bohr: A Very Short Introduction (2020) is also an excellent resource, although again often rather technical. On quantum mechanics generally, Kragh’s Quantum Generations and Heilbron and Jim Baggott’s recent Quantum Drama both do a great job of separating fact from myth. And to get a sense of how Bohr was regarded by his contemporaries and collaborators, the old collected volume Niels Bohr (1967), edited by Stefan Rozental, is indispensable.
In all honesty, I did not expect to bring substantially new perspectives to what one can find in sources like these; my job was rather to offer a comprehensible synthesis for general readers. But as I mentioned, I do hope too that I have been able to clarify some of the misconceptions around the Copenhagen view, especially that of Bohr himself. There is now a great deal of experimental work that has shed light on the issues about which Bohr argued with Einstein, and here I hoped to get beyond the rather simplistic reading in the popular-science literature according to which Bohr has been proved right (by Bell-test experiments) and Einstein wrong. It’s not as simple as that!
I hope too that I have been able to show that Bohr had a rather unique way of doing science, which relied to a sometimes-disconcerting degree on intuition, with the maths delegated subsequently to his more theoretically inclined younger collaborators. Bohr had a particular style, and that was reflected in his science—challenging the common idea that it really doesn’t matter who actually does the science because in the end only the objective truth matters. I think that Bohr shaped the way we think about quantum mechanics in a way that it’s hard to imagine coming from anyone else.
More generally, my aim has been to present through Bohr’s life an account of the trajectory of 20th-century physics, from the discovery of radioactivity and the Rutherford atom to the founding of CERN (in which Bohr played a role) and the beginning of Big Physics.
TO: The book draws extensively on oral histories preserved by AIP’s Niels Bohr Library & Archives. What did these firsthand accounts contribute to your understanding of Bohr and the scientific community around him?
PB: They were extremely valuable, indeed essential. These accounts offer the kind of personal perspectives that I don’t think one can find in any of the technical writings of these scientists—revealing the tensions between personalities, the conceptual struggles, and the different focuses of the various players. Of course, at the same time one should not regard these accounts as definitive statements of what happened, not least because they are referring to events that typically occurred many decades before the interviews. One can occasionally see how the interviewees have misremembered events, and sometimes they admit themselves that their memories are uncertain. There is of course very often an aspect of the retrospective stories we tell that is self-serving, or that fits a narrative we have shaped for ourselves that may or may not correspond to the reality. This unreliability of the narrator is of course the bread and butter of the work of historians!
Bohr, Franck, and Hansen Converse, Courtesy Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Margrethe Bohr Collection, Fermi Film Collection. Catalog ID: Bohr Niels C27
TO: You note that many textbook accounts of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics bear “only a crude resemblance to what Bohr himself thought.” What do you think has been most misunderstood or lost from Bohr’s, and his contemporaries’, original lines of thought?
PB: One thing that is often said of Bohr is that he was obscure, vague, hard to understand. I can’t deny that this is sometimes the case, but I think it is overblown and also misdirected. Bohr wasn’t a great communicator, but the difficulty of interpreting what he wrote is often a result of his difficulty in finding the right words for things that are extremely hard to express. He cared very deeply about language, and about finding the most appropriate way to talk about quantum theory, and the difficulty of doing so caused him much anguish. Victor Weisskopf put it well: “Niels Bohr was a very bad speaker, because he was too much concerned with the truth.” So while it is reasonable sometimes to get frustrated and impatient with Bohr’s apparent obscurity (and also, in truth, with his very laborious way of writing), I think there is something admirable in the seriousness with which he approached the philosophical implications of quantum mechanics. I find that certainly far preferable to the way in which many discussions of quantum physics today—not just in the popular press but in the technical literature—fall back on standard clichés (such as superpositions being about particles in two places at once) that, by seeming to impose classical stories on the quantum world, miss precisely the point that Bohr was trying to stress.
I get particularly unhappy about the way that von Neumann’s “wavefunction collapse” gets presented as a part of the Copenhagen interpretation. It never was. Bohr never used that phrase in any of his writings. Rather, Bohr’s view of the quantum-to-classical transition relied on his notion of complementarity. I don’t think that by any means took care of the problem, but we shouldn’t misrepresent him. (I’m not a fan of complementarity in general, which would have disappointed Bohr!) Another issue on which he is sometimes not done justice is his alleged anti-realism: the idea that there is no reality beyond what we can observe and measure. Bohr’s view was more subtle than that, as Max Schlosshauer has written about very perceptively.
I challenge too the idea, expounded in particular by Mara Beller in her book Quantum Dialogue (1999), that Bohr was a guru who bullied everyone into going along with the Copenhagen interpretation and who perhaps wasn’t even that much of a physicist. I think the historical evidence says otherwise. As Heilbron and Baggott point out, the fact that the Copenhagen view became seen as the orthodoxy owes more to the unfortunate aversion to the “philosophical” foundational issues that developed especially in the US from around the 1950s.
Bohr and Oppenheimer Converse, Courtesy of the Emilio Segrè Visual Archives General Collection, Niels Bohr Archive, Catalog ID: Bohr Niels C79
TO: A recurring theme in the book is the struggle with language in physics. You quote Bohr’s observation that “We are suspended over a bottomless pit, caught in our own words.” How did you navigate those challenges of language and explanation when reconstructing Bohr’s thinking for contemporary readers?
PB: Well, it wasn’t easy! I have done what I can to reconstruct what Bohr really thought and intended, and here I owe an immense debt to scholars who have thought about this with more insight and understanding than I. I have also tried to avoid the trap, evident among his disciples, of supposing that when Bohr is hard to understand, he must be saying something profound. After one meeting with Bohr, Carl von Weizsäcker asked himself “What had Bohr meant? What must I understand to be able to tell what he meant and why was he right?” Well, Bohr wasn’t always right, and I have tried to be fair in assessing when he is saying something that deserves effort in understanding and when he is merely waffling or saying something insubstantial (as we all do!). And Bohr’s love of paradoxes and contradictions, while perhaps somewhat appropriate for talking about quantum theory, can occasionally be exasperating. If there’s a contradiction, he’d say, it means we’re getting somewhere. But sometimes it just means that there’s a problem that needs fixing!
The key point here, as I’ve said, is to recognize that Bohr really cared about finding the right words, even if sometimes he failed to do so. That effort seems admirable to me—he wasn’t content with mere “truthiness,” to use Dan Dennett’s term.
TO: You recount Bohr’s efforts to persuade political leaders of the implications of atomic weapons. After an unsuccessful meeting with Winston Churchill, Bohr lamented that they “did not even speak the same language.” What does his experience suggest about the opportunities and limits of scientists’ engagement in public policy and society more broadly?
PB: Bohr had a perhaps naïve but also endearing belief that politicians like Churchill could be won over by reason and patient explanation. His meeting with Churchill was always headed for disaster, because Bohr was so slow, soft-spoken and long-winded—he wanted dialogue—whereas Churchill expected people to get to the point right away. But although Churchill doesn’t come across at all sympathetically in these accounts—he simply could not grasp how much the atomic bomb would change postwar international affairs, and he had a simplistic faith in state secrecy—one can sympathize with the need of politicians to have concise information on which they can act, and moreover information that speaks to political realities and not to idealized worlds.
Bohr was also over-optimistic about his Open Letter to the United Nations in 1950 calling for more openness and cooperation between nations, and in particular between the West and East, in matters of nuclear policy. The letter was essentially ignored, despite Bohr’s status among scientists. A lesson we can perhaps take from that is that scientists need to seek institutional structures for making their voice heard. Some of these now exist, for example the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (even if its warnings have been insufficiently heeded). The postwar period also saw the beginnings of formalized structures for feeding scientific advice into government, exemplified by Vannevar Bush’s famous 1945 report Science, the Endless Frontier. Bohr never really adopted this model, but I think he deserves great credit for seeing so clearly that scientists in the modern age had duties and responsibilities not just to their technical work but to society in general.
Niels and Margrethe Bohr Outdoors, Courtesy Emilio Segrè Visual Archives, Dodge Collection. Catalog ID: AR 352
TO: Finally, which biographies or other works of history and literature most influenced how you approached writing this book, and what did you take from them?
PB: I have to confess that I don’t think biography is my natural metier, even though I greatly enjoyed working on this one! So I didn’t really look for models in how to approach it. But I have been deeply impressed by Graham Farmelo’s biography of Paul Dirac, The Strangest Man, David Cassidy’s of Heisenberg, Beyond Uncertainty, and John Heilbron’s of Max Planck, The Dilemmas of an Upright Man. In different ways, they all combine profound scholarship with readability and insight. I think one needs to get from a biography not just a sense of “what happened” but of why it mattered, and of the person behind it.
For the history of the nuclear age and the bomb project, of course Richard Rhodes’ The Making of the Atomic Bomb remains definitive and incomparable. If ever I was finding gaps in the story I was telling about that aspect of Bohr’s life, Rhodes would be sure to fill it.