Visa and immigration policy: The October 2025 APS-led amicus brief
Data collected by the American Physical Society in 2020 showed that at that time perceptions that the US is unwelcome to foreigners and the hassle of the US visa and immigration system were already leading causes of PhD students choosing not to study in the US. APS cited the report in a “friend of the court” brief in October 2025 in support of a challenge to SEVIS record terminations.
APS Office of Government Affairs, “Building America’s STEM Workforce: Eliminating Barriers and Unlocking Advantages,” January 2021.
APS argues capricious visa enforcement hinders science recruiting
Recent developments with student visas are not specific to science students, but they, and the scientific enterprise overall, can certainly be affected by them. The American Physical Society (an AIP Member Society) has taken an interest in the matter, and on October 25, 2025 it led twelve other scientific societies in submitting an amicus curiae brief in support of the suit led by the President’s Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration. The brief states:
“Amici maintain that that the ability of the United States to remain competitive in scientific and technological fields relies heavily on foreign-born individuals who come to the United States as students…. An unreliable, inconsistent, or capricious U.S. visa process undermines international students’ confidence in the system and contributes to a perception that the United States is unwelcoming to foreign students, thereby significantly and measurably harming the ability of educational institutions in the United States to attract the best and brightest international scholars. Because the United States, with only 4% of the world population, does not have sufficient domestic science, technology, engineering, and math (“STEM”) capacity to meet its needs, the loss of talented international scientists will reduce the quality and quantity of the trained technical workforce and harm the nation’s economy and security.
The current U.S. visa system, although complex, ordinarily offers a stable process and settled requirements that allow the top global talent to pursue their careers in and contribute to the United States. Defendants’ recent actions have changed that, creating a challenging and uncertain visa process that harms not only the students whose visas are canceled and the schools who lose those talented and promising students, but also the reputation of the United States as the most desirable destination for the brightest budding science scholars.”
The brief cites surveys the American Physical Society conducted in 2019 and 2020, documenting drops in applications and enrollment from international students. Respondents indicated at that time that delays in visa processing were a significant barrier for international students, and a significant fraction of students perceived the United States to be unwelcoming.1
AIP Policy Research, “The October 2025 APS-led amicus brief,” Visa and immigration policy guide, American Institute of Physics, 2026, https://www.aip.org/research/visa-immigration/aps-amicus-brief.