The National Center for Atmospheric Research’s Mesa Lab in Colorado.
UCAR / CC BY-NC 4.0
NCAR operator sues NSF and White House over dismantling plans
The National Science Foundation has already made plans to transfer operations and maintenance of the National Center for Atmospheric Research’s Wyoming Supercomputing Center to the University of Wyoming or another “third party managing entity,” according to a lawsuit filed last week by the University Consortium for Atmospheric Research, NCAR’s operator. NSF notified NCAR’s director of the plans in February, weeks before the period to submit proposals for transfer plans ended and responses could be considered. NSF does not plan to transfer the R&D activities that depend on the supercomputing center, according to the February letter from NSF. The lawsuit also references a whistleblower complaint to Rep. Joe Neguse’s (D-CO) office alleging that Trump administration officials began discussing the transfer of NCAR’s space weather program to a private company in January, before NSF had formally reviewed any proposals. Additionally, the lawsuit states that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration terminated a multi-million-dollar agreement with NCAR’s operator under the Climate Adaptation and Mitigation Program following the White House’s announcement that it would “break up” NCAR. UCAR alleges that federal agencies have also unconstitutionally restricted its employees’ speech by forbidding them from publicly discussing any restructuring.
The lawsuit says the White House’s plans to dismantle NCAR are part of “a series of punishments targeted at Colorado,” where NCAR is headquartered. The lawsuit adds that the agencies lack “any legitimate programmatic rationale for the actions” because they have not identified any performance deficiency with UCAR. Furthermore, the plans undermine the agencies’ and the administration’s broader priorities, the lawsuit states. It says Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s “commitment to weather forecasting modernization and ‘innovation’... will be adversely impacted by any action that disrupts supercomputing functions or divests authority from the organization most knowledgeable and capable of overseeing the supercomputing center — namely, NCAR.” The lawsuit also alleges that NSF lacks the authority to transfer stewardship of NCAR under its current agreement with UCAR, which ends on Sept. 30, 2028.
DOE Office of Science Advisory Committee to meet Friday
The Department of Energy’s Office of Science Advisory Committee will hold its first public meeting on Friday. The committee was formed last year when six former advisory committees were rolled into one as part of wider efforts by the Trump administration to reduce the number of non-statutory advisory committees in the federal government. The committee’s membership was announced earlier this year.
A tentative agenda for the meeting includes updates from the Office of Science and Under Secretary for Science Darío Gil, as well as a discussion of the Genesis Mission, quantum information science, and the office’s user facilities. The meeting comes following an announcement last week that the Office of Science is making multiple changes to the organization of its sub-offices, including merging the High Energy Physics and Nuclear Physics offices. The Fusion Energy Sciences office was notably left unchanged in the latest reorganization, despite rumors that it would be rolled into the department’s newly created Office of Fusion. Under Secretary Gil reportedly announced at the Fusion Industry Association’s annual conference last week that Jean Paul Allain, the current head of the Fusion Energy Sciences office, will become the new director of the Office of Fusion, with the acting head of the soon-to-be merged Nuclear Physics office, Linda Horton, taking over FES on a temporary basis.
Comment period closing on proposed rule impacting all federal grants
The window to submit public comments on a proposed General Services Administration rule impacting federal grant applications will close on March 30. All applicants applying for grants from a federal agency are required to register with SAM.gov, and GSA’s proposed rule would ask applicants to certify that they will follow anti-discrimination laws in line with recent guidance from the Department of Justice and an executive order from President Donald Trump regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion programs. According to the education consulting firm Education Counsel, the changes “could seek to contractually bind almost all federal grantees — across all agencies, including the U.S. Department of Education — to the Administration’s interpretations of what is lawful or unlawful regarding DEI; immigration; terrorism/public safety; and free speech/religious liberty” with potential penalties for funding recipients that do not comply.
National Academies hosts Space Science Week
Several science agency officials will share space-related updates at the National Academies’ Space Science Week plenary on Tuesday, including representatives from NASA, the Department of Energy, the National Science Foundation, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, as well as European, Chinese, Indian, and Japanese space agencies. Various Academies committees on space will also meet throughout the week. The conference will feature two joint sessions on Wednesday, one focused on AI use in the space sciences and another on Dark and Quiet Skies for astronomy. The Committee on Radio Frequencies will receive updates from the Federal Communications Commission, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration, and NSF’s spectrum management program and Spectrum Innovation Center. The Committee on Astronomy and Astrophysics will receive updates on NSF’s astronomy work and facilities and DOE’s Cosmic Frontier program, which works to understand the nature of dark matter and dark energy.
Trump unveils AI legislative framework
The Trump administration published a national policy framework for artificial intelligence last week, urging Congress to create a single set of principles guiding AI development and consumer protections, rather than a “patchwork of conflicting state laws.” Leading House Republicans have endorsed the plan, but the proposal is already facing criticism from Democrats and some state officials, who warn that preempting state laws could weaken AI oversight.
The framework calls to remove “barriers to innovation” in AI development. It argues that Congress should avoid creating new regulatory bodies for AI and instead give that responsibility to existing organizations. It also argues that training AI models on copyrighted material does not violate copyright laws, but “acknowledges arguments to the contrary,” leaving the door open for Congress or courts to impose copyright-related restrictions on model development. It also calls on Congress to “streamline” permitting for AI infrastructure and power generation, but without allowing power demand from AI data centers to cause residential consumers to pay higher rates for electricity.
Also on our radar
The European Data Protection Board raised concerns to the European Commission about proposed changes to the U.S. ESTA program that would collect information such as visitors’ social media activity in the last five years and their family members’ personal data. The ESTA program is frequently used by scientists visiting the U.S. for conferences.
GSA and NIST’s Center for AI Standards and Innovation announced a joint effort last week to strengthen how the federal government tests and evaluates AI before agencies and the federal workforce start using it in real-world settings.
States sued the EPA last week over its rescission of the endangerment finding, which underpinned the agency’s authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions. The lawsuit joins another filed by environmental groups in February.
The House Science Committee advanced the NOAA Weather Radio Modernization Act. The bill directs NOAA to update emergency weather alert systems and requires the agency to notify the committee if it makes staffing changes that could impact its weather forecasting capacity.
DOE is now accepting applications from teams interested in using AI to tackle the science and technology challenges identified as part of the agency’s Genesis Mission. DOE plans to make initial awards of $500,000 to $750,000 to each project from a fund of $293 million.
The current national quantum strategy needs several improvements, according to a GAO report: performance measures to gauge progress on quantum computing, an established level of resources and infrastructure needed, specific roles and responsibilities for federal agencies, and integration of agency-level plans. OSTP has neither agreed nor disagreed with the recommendation, the report states.
GAO found that federal agencies do not consistently report spending data for other transaction agreements (OTAs) and has identified issues with the completeness and accuracy of subaward data on USAspending.gov.
The Trump administration is continuing its crackdown on union representation within federal science agencies on national security grounds, with DOE recently moving to terminate two collective bargaining agreements and NASA changing some employees’ union eligibility status, per reporting by GovExec.
Know of an opportunity for scientists to engage in science policy? Email us at fyi@aip.org.
Do you have a story to tell about how science policy is impacting you?
AIP’s research team is gathering first-hand accounts from scientists, engineers, students, and staff whose careers have been affected by policy and funding changes over the past year. Volunteers can submit their stories via this online form. Participants’ stories will be added to the Niels Bohr Library & Archives digital repository as searchable, citable records — with options for anonymity and a five-year embargo period. Read more about the initiative here.
Around the Web
News and views currently in circulation. Links do not imply endorsement.